Подтвердите e-mail

Для публикаций, комментариев, реакций и сообщений подтвердите адрес.

Публикация

Someone sent me this.

Обсуждение

193 прямых ответов · 309 сообщений

Показаны не все ответы

Публичный счётчик показывает 196, а источник передал 193. Остальные ответы могли быть удалены, скрыты или не выданы публично.

So he's secretly a black feminist? Or just like to plagiarize from one?

Ответ для Alexander Dent

He probably uses the cognitive frames of intersectional feminism but inverts the moral valence, much like Ayn Rand understood the world like a Marxist but with a commitment to “evil, be thou my good”

Ответ для Joel

Probably!

Ответ для Joel

I mean, that’s what he does with catholic doctrine. When he talked about “god wanting hierarchical love”, he was perverting a medieval (i think) text he read that says the *exact* opposite.

Ответ для enots406

So he’s the second dumbest student

Ответ для Alexander Dent

Well, if it works/worked for Melanoma? (Wait, which one of those assholes did it first?Eh, 🤷‍♀️ Doesn’t matter. They are still plagiarizing assholes.)

Ответ для Alexander Dent

That group really loves plagiarizing Black women. With a side (gaslighting) whine of “but it’s religion.”

He's never had an original thought in his life. He was taken to Silicon Valley to be groomed by Peter Thiel & mentored by Curtis Yarvin. He obliged them, completely changing his values & personality. I don't know how Usha stays with such a weak man. He's not the person she married. Is she a hostage?

Ответ для Zen Zinnia

She clerked for Brett Kavanaugh and stood on the RNC stage while people waved “Mass Deportation Now” signs. She’s awful in her own right. Idk why people are so eager to give wives of republicans an out, or imagine them to be victims.

Ответ для 10milestereo

the innocent wife trope is among my least favorite.

Ответ для Tressie McMillan Cottom

I don't think she's innocent, but even Vance said she didn't necessarily want another child. Then, just as rumors come out about him and Erika Kirk, she turns up pregnant again with her 4th, and Vance is bragging on camera about how he got his way. It's just all so icky.

Ответ для Zen Zinnia

I suspect she knows how to prevent pregnancies. Still don’t know how this makes her his hostage and not his collaborator.

Ответ для Tressie McMillan Cottom

We'll never know what they discussed privately, but there's a lot of talk among the men in the current regime about taking agency away from women. They want to disenfranchise us, ban abortion and contraception, and some of them attend the CREC church that condones husbands raping their wives.

Ответ для Zen Zinnia

I am confused, again, as to why these powerful women wouldn't be collaborators in that and why its so self-evident to you that they must be victims.

Ответ для Tressie McMillan Cottom

I'm not arguing with you. I'm saying that we don't know what goes on behind closed doors. In her recent interview, it seemed obvious that she doesn't share her husband's views but didn't feel as though she could say so. People who speak out have died. Kirk, Epstein, multiple trafficking victims.

Ответ для Tressie McMillan Cottom

I wouldn't be surprised if Usha "fell down the stairs" like Ivana Trump did the night before she was scheduled to give a sworn deposition in the trial against her ex-husband.

Ответ для Zen Zinnia

It’s easier than that to lose a fetus you don’t want (and maybe doesn’t even exist to begin with).

Ответ для Tressie McMillan Cottom

Two seemingly opposite things can both be true; some Epstein victims became recruiters. I fall more or less here: A 40% chance Usha is 100% collaborator, sold her soul from the get go, 60% chance she’s some balance of collab and victim, 0% chance she’s 100% victim.

Ответ для trouvera 🇨🇦 🍁

I can agree with that. She was a registered Democrat right up until her husband ran for the Senate and she voted for him.

Ответ для Zen Zinnia

No - they were matched by Amy Chua. Amy "TigerMom" Chua prob taught JD everything that the couch did not.

Ответ для Zen Zinnia

No. And neither is Melania Trump

I am upset

I sense the P word will be used. 😉

FWIW, the church on his Communion book ain’t even Catholic—it’s a stock photo of a Methodist church in KY.

Ответ для Dave Fortin

Here's a link so y'all know I'm not just blowing smoke: www.thedailybeast.com/embarrassing...

Embarrassing Blunder on Vance’s Catholic Book Cover ExposedThe vice president’s newly announced memoir about his conversion to the faith is already hitting some snags.www.thedailybeast.com

Wow. I didn’t think I could hate this guy more, and yet...

what would Harald Bloom say

Ответ для 𝖘𝖆𝖘𝖍𝖆 𝖊 𝖍𝖊𝖆𝖉

you couldnt get a real photograph of a beautiful vista crafted by god's own hand you had to generate it AHGHHHGG

Good God... they really don't have an original thought, do they?

Ответ для Ebony Elizabeth Thomas

they want to displace great work by Black women with their grievance farmer slop

Ответ для Julia Is Waving, Not Drowning
Ответ для Tommy Valdez
Ответ для Julia Is Waving, Not Drowning

grievance farmer slop!!!!

Ответ для Ebony Elizabeth Thomas

Every single time I think I can't despise that man more. Let the discipline of sociology meet him behind the Denny's.

Ответ для Ebony Elizabeth Thomas

Like when Melania stole Michelle’s speech

Everybody buy and read bell hooks

New JD Vance Bell Hooks prompt just dropped

Do not ever buy any Couch Fucker books.

I am aghast. Once might be a coincidence, but twice? Abhorrent Alt text below with full book titles (and publish dates) in the reply

flyingawaynow

Alt text: On the left side, there are 2 books by bell hooks, a Black woman and respected writer on race, feminism, and class who lived and was a distinguished professor in KY. The books are Communion and Appalachian Elegy On the right, there are 2 books by JD Vance: Communion and Hillbilly Elegy

no

Ответ для Bellamy Dryden 🌿

The only communion book to read.

Weird…

Plagerism of titles?

Ответ для Lu 💙

Also appropriation of cover design. It it was anyone else, it could be seen as a coincidence, but with jd, I'm comfortable saying he's actively trying to erase a Black woman's ideas.

Ответ для AV🕯️ Ctrl+Alt+Del

Yes

bell hooks ALL UPPER-CASE J D VANCE

As a joke?! 🇬🇧 so probably don't get it. Get thee to alawyer JD, midterms are coming.

God help us if he tries to speak on Belonging

Ответ для one island after another

Ok, literally laughing SO loud now

Ответ для one island after another

What about Michelle Obama's Becoming?

omg

Vance can’t even come up with his own titles. 😂😂😂

What the fucking fuck?! In addition to all his other horrible traits and actions, so many of which are racist, sexist, & capitalist, JD Vance steals/plagiarizes book titles from the incomparable African American feminist scholar bell hooks?! #PINKS

I used to think the only thing I liked about hillbilly elegy was the title and now I know it’s bc he stole it from bell hooks

And the best part is that the church on the cover is methodist, NOT catholic...

Ответ для isinqueens

Finally looked up the church where he was supposedly converted by an Opus Dei priest and it’s in the richest neighborhood in Cincinnati

Ответ для Elle

Cincinnati's Catholics in the mid 20th century were the center of white flight. They moved to Northern Kentucky, sent all their children to catholic schools to exclude black people, and then cut taxes to pay for everything except roads to their 95%+ white suburbs.

Ответ для Rarian Rakista

Yes, but Indian Hill didn’t really let anyone in. It’s still “farmland” surrounded by Anderson and Kenwood

Ответ для Elle

Look at places like Union, Kentucky. They abandoned the 20th century suburbs when even 10% of the population was non-white to further retreat into the countryside. They built "country clubs" in the 2000's that now vet members before they can buy condos or houses. 95% white again.

Ответ для Rarian Rakista

Ok but I am talking about Vance’s Catholic conversion story book cover, which is a Methodist church in the hills of Appalachia.

Ответ для Elle

bell hooks grew up in Appalachia. Vance grew up here and so did his mother:

Violence

I’m not enjoying the writing of this season of Reality. It’s too trite.

Ответ для Lucy 🌌💎
Ответ для Jeff (no, getdafuqouttamyreflectingpool one)

Absolutely phoning it in

Oh..

I am sorry to say that I bought Hillbilly Elegy. I realized as I read it that I had enough of Vance, but I didn't want to transmit him to anyone else, so I put the book in my garage, where silverfish slowly ate it. "The humblest of all God's creatures" did us all a favor.

The white nationalists are attempting to rewrite history. I just bought another copy of Bell’s books and I will search on Bell’s books a million times on Google til she is ranking #1.

Ответ для Tipsy McStagger

Nice. I'll join you in that endeavor.

Ответ для AV🕯️ Ctrl+Alt+Del

Same.

it feels like a political alignment chart that escaped the group chat

creepy

The Vance “Teaching to Transgress” and “killing rage” will be something to behold.

Ответ для Laura Mariko Cheifetz (she/her)

And Yearning.

If only he had read them and been changed for the better. If he did read them it was to know his enemy.

😑

Wait...I did not draw this connection! Wtf

Whiskey Tango Foxtrot!

This is honestly some blasphemy

Ответ для Frankie Huang 黄碧赤

Exactly. My first thought was sacrilege.

💀

Uhh..

goddammit

Shady Vance and plagiarism are common with the GQP.

tressie what the absolute fuck

Ответ для paul johnson

That’s exactly what I said. Like, what are we looking at here?? A bit?!

Ответ для Tressie McMillan Cottom

An extremely unfunny one

Ответ для Tressie McMillan Cottom
Ответ для Tressie McMillan Cottom

A bot.

Performance christian Believe what I tell you

It's too early in the day for me to be this mad.

Speechless

some bell hooks and some hell books

Ответ для Walker Robins

hats off to you

Ответ для Walker Robins

👏🏿👏🏿

Ответ для Walker Robins

⭐️

Ответ для Walker Robins

dang

Ответ для Walker Robins

Magnificent! A+!

Ответ для Walker Robins

This comment had gotten a lot of ❤️ & it's still underrated 👏🏽

Oh lord have mercy

Ответ для Faine Greenwood

I am increasingly feeling as if they are absolutely not having any mercy, and that is distressing.

👀 I can’t unsee that.

Books his wife recommended to him while they were dating. Neither of them read either one.

The depths of my utter disgust with that man are absolutely impossible to articulate

Damn!😳

👀

We are all buying Communion, by Bell Hooks on the others release date on 6/16/26, correct?

🤝

Wait...what the heck is going on?

Ответ для Dominique Baker

honestly from the interviews with his Yale pals (except Ramaswamy) about what he was like then I wouldn't be shocked if he read a lot of bell hooks and would now vehemently deny it.

Ответ для Dominique Baker

We have to discuss this.

Ответ для Tressie McMillan Cottom

Lemme be a fly on the wall

Ответ для Brit Williams, Ph.D.

Can I attend this webinar!

Ответ для Tressie McMillan Cottom

Great way to game book search results and erase knowledge as a consequence

Ответ для bdonnelly

Ooh, I didn't think about this.

Ответ для bdonnelly

This makes sense.

Ответ для bdonnelly

💯🎯

Ответ для bdonnelly

Exactly. I saw someone call it a coincidence and I was like, nah, I don't think so.

Ответ для Bex is WEAK on crime

The first book title *maaaaybe…* but now? That’s enemy action

Ответ для bdonnelly

Colonizing SEO

Ответ для bdonnelly

My response exactly.

Ответ для Tressie McMillan Cottom

Oh we're gonna.

Ответ для Tressie McMillan Cottom

It almost seems not accidental.

Ответ для Carole

do you believe in coincidence?

Ответ для Tressie McMillan Cottom

Not a creative bone in his body. But I do wonder if he has ever read bell hooks. I would be surprised if he has.

Ответ для AnneC

he wore a completely different costume when he was in college as I understand it. For example, ****gasp****he had queer/trans friends who he didn’t dehumanize

Ответ для Dominique Baker

“flooding the zone“ is real

Ответ для Dominique Baker

He really thought no one knew who bell hooks was.

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The fash always try to steal that of which they are most envious. They believe it makes them look witty, and (ironically) devalues the object of their thievery. There is only one Bell Hooks. No one will ever say that about the empty, replicable vessel that is JD Vance.

This is like when there's a really popular show Netflix doesn't have, but they DO have a cut-rate show with almost the same name that pops on the "recommended" and "popular" suggestions.

The Insta take back (buying and reading both of hooks’ books) was a wonderful thing.

huh. well how about that.

Ответ для molly conger

Phew, what

Ответ для Mel Buer

lots to consider here but i’d rather not!!!

Ответ для molly conger

looking at it nearly took me out.

Someone does not like you @tressiemcphd.bsky.social

K

This is appalling and super weird.

What the fuck?!?!

Wtaf

coming up next, The Desire to Change

I can/can’t believe my eyes The gall This cuts me so deep how intentional this must have been and it took me this long to see it

"The will to change" will complete this trilogy when it's time for his post-Trump pivot.

Ответ для aj-boston.neocities.org

Or maybe "Triumph of the Will to Change"

looking at this, I feel like I'm having a stroke

Ответ для Unsubtly

omg the RAGE!

Ответ для Megan S.

My reaction, yesterday, was to scream, “Keep her name outchea, filthy, mouth!”

Does the D stand for Dolezal?

I need a journalist to ask about this because JD Vance will say he doesn’t know who that is and we’ll all get to watch him learn about bell hooks in real time

...in ter est ing

She can no longer speak about this.

Where We Stand: Heritage Matters

When his bookshelf circulated, some were convinced he’d never read any of it, claimed books were picked by set dresser. I don’t think that’s right—think there’s a real + much knottier relationship to left-liberal canon. Everyone in YLS FedSoc knows these texts well enuf to fuel antagonism for them.

dell cameron

computer, enhance

Ответ для C.H. Romatowski

Or, ambivalence might be a better way to put it than solely antagonism, because clearly there’s a level of attraction too.

Ответ для C.H. Romatowski

I think they’re wrong. I would absolutely assume he has read them. But then I’m a little stupid.

Ответ для Tressie McMillan Cottom

He has hate read at least some bell hooks

Next up for JD: I ain’t a woman: White men and feminism

Its funny because belle hooks is Vance's drag name.

Ответ для Wonderful Starfish

But man, a lot of her titles would sound reeeeaaallll different coming out of his mouth: Outlaw Culture Killing Rage Teaching to Transgress Art on my Mind The Will to Change Writing Beyond Race Remembered Rapture Uncut Funk

Pope Leo should ex-communicate this fraud for breaking the Third Commandment.

oh my

Doesn’t seem like a coincidence, but do you think he reads, or is even aware of bell hooks? Maybe his publisher decided this?

j d vance

Wow. I guess next we’ll have Teaching to Regress. Or better yet, Teaching, What Teaching?

Vance, or should I say James Donald Bowman, was raised to believe that Plagiarism is the most sincere form of flattery.

Part of the right-wing‘s MO is to co-opt and appropriate cultural (mostly liberal / left) ideas and forms of expression. This is 100% intentional and malicious.

I hadn't noticed, but if bell hooks were alive she would have seen it.

👀

Someone do a phot shop work up of JD Vance’s teaching to trangress

Omg! They’re never original

Here we thought plagiarism was a personal favorite only of the MAGAphucka’s Third Anchor Baby Mama💁🏽‍♀️ only to learn it’s an Administration policy/procedure 🤦🏽‍♀️

Oh no. Search engine and keyword manipulation to override some of the most influential writings of our time.

On the Vance side: the sort of hillbillies who go to that sort of church think that Catholics are demonic. (Generic church bulletin church - very careful that nothing identifies it as Catholic.)

Smh

this made my morning.

“JD Vance is an op designed to lead far-right partisans to the work of bell hooks via SEO manipulation” I whisper to myself, shuffling slowly around the common room after activity time

Oh hell no

I think we know what’s next…

Ugh

jd vance: hillbilly elegy 2016 communion 2026 bell hooks: communion 2002 appalachian elegy 2012

Ответ для petenorway

Is he smart enough to do something like that?

Ответ для Jenn S.

No, but Thiel is rich enough to pay someone to think of it, and he masterminded the conversion.

Ответ для Elise

Ahh… now that makes sense.

I always wondered if JD Vance actually knew what an elegy was?

Ответ для Zaneta GA

Narrator: he did not and does not. Not even if it bit him in the ass. not even if it set his couch ablaze?

Literally gasped

This is 1000% what Naomi Klein refers to as the Mirror World in Doppelgänger: it’s co-opting the feelings without concern for the facts.

i'm going back to bed

Ответ для Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò

What's insane is that the image and the location of the books also mimics a political compass/nolan chart. Just not sure how I'd label the axes exactly.

Ответ для Southey Blanton

l: selflessness r: selfishness t: spiritual b: secular

They sent this to intentionally annoy you?

What the actual fuck?

What the actual

Can we make Bell Hooks' works top the search engines, by looking for these with her name?

If his next book is titled something like “A Few Things About Love” I’ll lose it

Ответ для An aunt

“All about hate”

Totally different. I meant look… ALL CAPS! 🙃

That maliciously vacuous amoral smirking little demon.

Ответ для DidntWeAlmostHaveItAll

Oh, you said it so well!

Well, can't unsee that.

Alt text version

I-

Next up... "All about love: A reflection on my time in the Tr**p White House"

Whoa

this tracks

The sound that just came out of me...

Hmmmmmm. Yeah that is curious in a f-ed up way.

What in the unholy fuck happened here

He’s obsessed. Green with envy.

Have any tables that need propping up? Recycle the papers as kitty litter? So many choices.

Oh damn.

Gross

He's going to say he never heard of bell hooks and that's going to send me into orbit.😑

Jaw on floor

He's deeply disturbed.

He's freakin Randall. 🤷‍♂️

Welp…I’ve never seen them in the same room together…

Holy Shhhhhh, just wild.

I'll take bell hooks, please, any day, any time. JD, not so much, well, never.

These guys never have an original thought.

Bell Hills needs to get a restraining order. Why anyone would want to read the testimony of a 45-year-old man on his third name and third religion about his Christian path? Give him a year and JD will be JR and a Southern Baptist.

Ответ для Upstate Dem

Lowkey hoping the Pope will personally expel him from the church; get some good excommunication in before Vance decides to leave on his own terms.

Ответ для Upstate Dem

bell hooks is alas no longer with us but looting her ideas is very on brand for this asshole

This feels like a peek into how his mind works. Gross

Some *one* or some *thing*? Unforgivable if the former, inhuman of the latter.

I am so NOT stunned. Because yes, of course. And… I just want to never see or hear from him ever again. Can’t we have that? Why can’t we have that.

Just watched a TikTok on this where they suggest that this could be an attempt to change Google results so his white nationalist religious book pops up instead of hooks' work. Devious shit.

This feels like cursed knowledge.

I'm sure you've seen this by now (you are mentioned): lithub.com/is-jd-vance-...

Is JD Vance stealing his book titles from bell hooks?As the internet noted earlier this week—and Claire Guinan at Jezebel observed yesterday—Vice President JD Vance may have a plagiarism problem. (Among his many others.) On Tuesday, the man with the …lithub.com

I learned about this from @couplestherapypod.bsky.social !

JFC 🤬🤬🤬🤬

🤯🤯😵‍💫😵‍💫🥵🥵🥵

Oh. Oh my god.

Ответ для Le Cagle

Wtaf

He's going full Melania.

What's next? "Brothers of The Yam?" If I had better photo editing skills, I'd start mocking up some predictive covers. I just know Lil' J.D. is salivating over, "Outlaw Culture."

I won't say JD Vance has been actively trying to erase bell hooks, Black woman feminist academic, by appropriating her book titles and covers. I'd use a different word.

Now curious who came up with his titles

I am so grateful today Gloria Watkins (rip) did not live to see this. However. You made me see it, and I’m not sure how I feel about that.

J.D. Vance's "Ain't I A Woman?" is going to be a real coup de grace.

Ответ для Matt Seybold

this sent coffee out of my nose

Ответ для Matt Seybold

Post of the day.

Ответ для Matt Seybold

😂😂😂😂😂

Ответ для Matt Seybold

J.D. Vance will have to cage fight Byron Noem for that one! He better triple up on the eyeliner.

Ответ для Matt Seybold

The photo of Vance in a wig and dress at a Yale Halloween party, head back and hands behind his head, is one of very few photos of him where you can sense a real, human person. It's the 'before' in an evil origin story www.snopes.com/fact-check/j...

Yes, Photos Do Show JD Vance Wearing Dress and Blonde Wig While at Yale Law School"JD put on a bad wig at a party in college - not exactly scandalous," a representative for Vance told Snopes via email.www.snopes.com
Ответ для Matt Seybold

Bought in a two-book deal along with JD’s other forthcoming “Sisters of the Yam”

Ответ для Matt Seybold

It'll be j d vance by that point I suppose

I like Bell Hooks writing, Vance not at all. You may already know about this critique of Hillbilly Elegy, if you don’t tropicsofmeta.com/2017/02/27/t...

The Self-Serving Hustle of “Hillbilly Elegy”JD Vance steps on the necks of his supposed kin in his ceaseless quest for avarice, self promotion, and power.tropicsofmeta.com

I know we are anti-AI. It was interesting reading how the Communion books intersect.

Ответ для Liz Jeanette

With the eraser of our history, anti-law, anti-democracy, anti-education, anti-multiculturalism, anti-constitution, etc... I know these things existed in drops but now... That piece of paper can always be changed. We know what to do. He can be removed right now. They all can. So why don't we?

Tressie through the looking glass.

I just deflated completely

………………………

I hope she haunts his a**

Nope. Nope. Noooope.

Ya'll can shove this book along with Jake Tapper's hatchet job on Biden and Comey's whiner and Bob Woodward's "lemme save the good stuff for $$ and not save the country."

There is not an original thought in his bowling ball head.

I…

out of all the nothing-makes-sense we've been experiencing lately, this is the nothing-makes-sensiest

Lord have mercy!!

One day his new book will sit at the peddlers mall for a dollar, gathering dust.

Ответ для Flapjack 🥞

I laid a hex that his book would be remaindered so fast.

Ugh.

"To the shock of everyone and the dismay of many, the most anticipated book of 2029 is JD Vance's 'Feminist Theory: From Margin to Center'"

Ответ для Wack Thought

I can actually imagine a cursed version of that one

Ответ для The Mórrígan

Probably a review of "Tradwife literature", selective TERF readings, and "a woman's right to choose [...] a life of devoted motherhood".

Ответ для Wack Thought

I’m actually reading that one (the original, I’m talking about) right now, wish I’d read it much, much earlier.

Ответ для The Mórrígan

Feminist Weary: From Center to Margin

Ответ для Kenji

Yeah, but that’s the ghost of bell hooks. Vance’s version would be much more cursed than even *that.*

I feel queasy

Well damn.

My soul is weary.

that’s downright spooky

I would prefer to read the ones on the left to the ones on the right (both literally and politically).