Подтвердите e-mail

Для публикаций, комментариев, реакций и сообщений подтвердите адрес.

Публикация

‘There are no rules’: spotlight on Gossip Goblin as AI film-making enters new era

‘There are no rules’: spotlight on Gossip Goblin as AI film-making enters new eraDefying criticisms of ‘slop’ and ‘theft’, the growing culture of AI-powered creativity is attracting interest from Hollywoodwww.theguardian.com
Обсуждение

147 прямых ответов · 176 сообщений

Показаны не все ответы

Публичный счётчик показывает 158, а источник передал 147. Остальные ответы могли быть удалены, скрыты или не выданы публично.

I wish everyone involved in this a very happy Prolapsed Rectum

Dude's entire ethos is "I can take anything that you can't prove you own." No rules, indeed.

no

Ответ для Trojan Duck

I came here to say this.

Slop is a little too kind - it's diarrhea out of the butt of actual creativity

Kill it with fire!

There is no such thing as ai creativity

Ответ для Thembo

Indeed. It's creative humans using AI.

Ответ для AiFlix

Incorrect, account created 20 minutes ago.

Ответ для Thembo

"Incorrect". Great rebuttal.

Ответ для AiFlix

Thank you, incorrect weirdo who created an account to immediately start whining at me in response to a month-old post.

Ответ для AiFlix

No, it's the least creative people using ai to badly copy existing creative works in a soulless way.

The only thing "attracting interest" is producers and companies not wanting to pay humans for art

Let these money-grubbing suits see what happens when they attempt to shovel this hot stinking slop in front of paying audiences. I suspect it will not go well for them.

AI-powered creativity must be the oxymoron of the day.

AI needs to be eradicated.

Disgusting failed puff piece on the theft of human labor and creativity.

I watched a few of these on Instagram and all his 'tough' characters just have Jason Statham's voice 😅

I'd rather watch a literal piece of shit because at least a person made that

For something you all claim everyone already wants you really spend a lot of energy, time, and money trying to convince people who dont want this shit that they do.

before AI I never would have had to look at this thing

Ответ для Opinion Editor @ Bluesky

Some rules are for the best

Ответ для Opinion Editor @ Bluesky

You would have probably did. Visually, it’s clearly stolen from Dobby in Harry Potter. 🫤

Sorry, I do have rules and a huge rule for my media consumption is "no ai" I literally don't care what they're making or trying to say, they can fuck off into the sun with it

they're not "defying" criticisms, they're ignoring them there's no such thing as "AI-powered creativity," because asking machines to make art for you is the opposite of creativity it's not a "culture," it's a scam run by wealthy sociopaths the part about there being no rules is correct though

to enter a “new era” i think you had to already be in an era of some kind

No such thing as AI art. This is slop and I deeply regret that my eyeballs have been subjected to this nightmare fuel

I cannot stress enough how little people will want to watch this trash

AI is theft, unethical, lazy, lackluster, unimaginative crap that no one - literally no one - wants.

Wow this is awful trash

It’s theft

lol no

Jesus christ this shit is such Ass

AI slop. It looks awful.

@robert-booth.bsky.social do you ever wish you were a real journalist?

Eewww what the hell is that

Ответ для LuckyTrashFox

A stain upon the wonderful medium that is animation

Riddle me this, if it's not theft then where do they get the data to train from,

No such thing as slop generation creativity, stop carrying water for this catastrophic industry.

Nothing @theguardian.com writes about AI can be trusted after this: www.theguardian.com/gnm-press-of...

Guardian Media Group announces strategic partnership with OpenAIGuardian Media Group today announced a strategic partnership with Open AI, a leader in artificial intelligence and deployment, that will bring the Guardian’s high quality journalism to ChatGPT’s globa...www.theguardian.com

Weird how the new era is also slop

Anti-Ai slogan-screechers really want this to be bad, and it's really good. Looking forward to seeing more from this filmmaker.

There are, in fact, rules in art. And like most rules, they work best when you know them *before* you break them, as opposed to ignoring their existence.

there’s no such thing as ai powered creativity

Yet to see it, or any other ai slop, at least I hope so.

And to think this is what humans choose over water and clean air. Sounds fun.

Fun fact: AI plagiarized works cannot be copyrighted, so you are free to steal this movie, you can even resell it.

Go piss, goblin Refill the image generator filters, they're running low on sickly yellow

You fucking morons

Nobody wants this but the bosses and empty suits and their PR lackeys.

new theory, the guardian is posting articles like this and the vape sommelier one here on purpose so next week they can do a whiny one about how bluesky is full of haters

Thanks, but no.

Ответ для Hangry Dad

Also, no thanks.

this sucks and i hate it

wow this sucks

They are lazy thieving assholes and yall are the enablers. Fuck off

Is it creativity or AI? It can't be both.

This is what you guys are predicting is the future of film. How embarrassing.

Ответ для Vera Moreijn

There is no creativity, there is no authorship, there are simply ideas that make a specific audience chuckle for two seconds but which they are simply too lazy to make. Calling these frauds filmmakers is the exact same as calling someone who asked ChatGPT to write a book an author.

Ответ для Vera Moreijn

Narrator: they are

It's a grift and these people should be beaten with sticks, then jailed. GenAI is theft, period.

Reminder that the Guardian has a deal with AI companies and are actively against the interests of workers and artists.

Why would I bother to watch something nobody bothered to make?

This is like syphilis, the brain eating amoeba, and cancer merged with ebola and Creutzfelt-Jakob into one big Disease Voltron

daft bastards

There are no rules And we like it that way.

Gossip Goblin is just the majority of the media these days

sure chief

Ответ для wifi burrito

what a coincidence!

Ответ для babs drinks tea

it coincidentally happens a few times a month even

AI “film” is made by and for people who are on their phones the entire movie

how about criticisms of 'shit' and 'a bunch of assholes'

‘Defying criticisms’ now there’s a solid sales pitch.

It’s still slop, & shit & I would absolutely kill Gossip Goblin with a hammer if it were real

AI “artists” are artists in the same way I’m a chef for ordering food. I will never pay to see an AI generated movie.

Ответ для So-called scientist

idk, ive seen some pretty good AI movies on social media. I love seeing the ones with the dogs lol. Maybe a nice dog video will change your mind :D

Ответ для airamx112.bsky.social 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈

I feel nothing watching AI animal videos. There are plenty of real dogs and cats I’d rather watch. Cats in particular are hilarious without AI.

Ответ для So-called scientist
Ответ для airamx112.bsky.social 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈

No AI cat will love me like my cat did. It can’t replace him. The point of cats is that they don’t do what you want. They do whatever their insane little minds want.

Ответ для airamx112.bsky.social 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈

The fun of it is the spontaneity and unpredictability If you can make them do whatever you want, you don't have a cat you have a robot

Ответ для airamx112.bsky.social 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈

wow if I ever say plagiarized nonsense is better than a real, wonderful, strange, soft, unpredictable cat, do a wellness check ASAP

Ответ для airamx112.bsky.social 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈

AI peddler, opinion discarded.

How about an era where they make something good?

Ответ для Luca🎞️

Love how you guys chose something that looks mystifyingly terrible as the main image for this story.

HOW TO MAKE SAFE A.G.I. (one chance): Step 1) Thoz who hate A.I. shouldn't uz it. That'll keep progress slowr & only thoz who like it as the main data to train frm. Step 2) Wait until the psyko, nerdy, i get no femalez, incel, weirdo, boomer CEOs making this tech for moar pwr... dy ⌚️

There’s no such thing as “AI filmmaking”.

Even if it wasn't built on theft and environmental vandalism, I can't imagine anything more boring and unsatisfying than spending my time prompting and fixing hallucinations. If that's what you call filmmaking you are not a filmmaker, you are a parasite.

"AI-powered creativity" lol lmao

Ответ для Kristian van der Vliet

Oh hey remember when we were all going to play games made with NFT assets and watch cartoons based on NFTs?

Data entry (“creative” prompt selection) is NOT art.

Jesus Christ talk about a jump scare. What is this demon ?

Maybe Robert Booth should go fuck himself

Ответ для Diogeneez Nutz

I'm just saying if I looked like this I would probably be just as impressed with the computer beep boops and this would disqualify me from talking forever

I have such a visceral and disturbed reaction to that image I’m simply not reading the article. How dare you put that shit in front of my eyes.

While watching Double Indemnity the other night one thing I did NOT think was, “I bet an algorithm could do this better.”

It's burning the planet, wasting water, built on theft and is shit, but sure, keep running adverts for it.

Don’t watch stolen AI slop.

Nah fuck that

Ai slop is unwanted. These people aren’t creators they are thieves.

Ответ для Skuzy

Calling it a fucking CRAFT. Fuck off with that.

It will never be like my precious Boc.

The rule is if it uses AI it sucks. This uses AI *and* it sucks. So simple even a baby could understand, so it makes sense these people are struggling with it.

"It's soulless, wildly expensive hackery built on plagiarism and wanton climate destruction. But it makes hippies mad and lets us fire a bunch of those dreadful ~creatives~ so win-win, right? That's worth burning a few million dollars and a couple of rainforests."

Ill never watch this shit.

Ah yes, when seeing AI slop my first reaction is always "I wish there was more of this slop and I could pay money to someone who used the plagiarism machine to create the slop".

it’s giving zuckerberg vibes

Looks like shit

yeah whatever losers nobody's watching a gnome named gnorm but worse

If he can make shorts this easily and simply, can he also make a bunch of fake Youtube accounts to engage with his posts to make it look like they are getting a further reach than they actually are?

a mom and pop slop shop, making bespoke, quaint AI, to avoid paying anyone for labor.

Reminder that if something is created using a plagiarism machine, you're justified in using it without paying for it.

There is no such thing as AI powered creativity.

Looks like boring garbage.

Well, Hollywood is known for making wise and sound decisions, better report on this like it's noteworthy. Say, what's David Zaslav up to right now?

No thanks

“creativity” and “ai” do not belong on the same sentence

This is the first I’m hearing of “Gossip Goblin” and it looks like trash

People should aspire to have some taste. And pride. Not make or watch whatever the fuck this is. Fucking like yourselves, damnit.

Garbage. I get even a whiff of AI, I will go to my grave without watching

Ответ для Jabroxen Brodium

I will never get tired of saying this either. I am a hard headed man. You could get me to swear off the whole medium by putting AI in every movie. I would just start making fun of people who watch movies that came out after 2025

"Growing culture" is shill speak for malignant cancer.

Finally, no gatekeepers on art!! I can say something really out there, something no stuffy studio will let me! My film: “technology can make human life complicated” A SHOCKING thematic angle. No Hollywood big shot would dare be this brave. I can see why this all worth it now.

Hi filmmaker here. There's no such fucking thing as AI filmmaking. It's just making slop. Hope that helps. Ya fuckin goofies.

🤮

>AI film-making enters new era new era in question: bankruptcy

this is too far im muting your account i can tolerate the liberal and fascist stupid opinions but posting AI slop is too far

Let's be clear, the people it's exciting in Hollywood are the money men, the talentless, soulless ghouls who think they've found a money tree that can churn out "hits" without them having to invest anything much or pay any actually talented people.

"But this had a distinctly homespun feel, the little team fussing over a monologue by a poetic Scottish gorilla inhabiting a transhumanist cyberpunk universe." Ah, those handmade AI films, all sweat and human input.

If Hollywood and Spotify kill movies tv and recorded music I will buy a fucking banjo and learn to play it. They can stick it.

Ответ для Felonious Musk

Oh and fuck you @theguardian.com

Stop rimming these thieving charlatans.

Human beings should reject AI entertainment content.

Ответ для dwchampion

it seems so simple!

This is trash

There is no such thing as AI film-making. AI steals actual art, mutates it grotesquely, and then resells it.

I cut the wires in the spotlight, stop making me look at this dogshit

bro they still can’t decide on the number of digits this cover freak should have, meantime there are REAL artists looking for work. this ugly, incompetent trash is a kind of cultural vandalism. stop. don’t do it. stop pushing this stupid ugly garbage that’s bad for everyone

There ARE rules. We will not see Gossip Goblin.

“AI film-making” 😂😂😂

"There are no rules" no rules for coherent storytelling, aesthetics, continuity, etc etc

No one is going to want to watch this shit

Well there is *one* rule, which is that if your film is AI slop, people are going to correctly tell you to shove it up your arse

Looks like shit

Absolutely FUCK this rage bait. Pic 1: *Love* this attempt to minimize concerns about AI film-making. What would *you* call the systemic theft of IP across decades of human work? Pic 2: Anyone using AI to make “art” has no business addressing “what it means to be human”.

They're all gonna be free right? I mean, they stole the parts to build it and nobody had to actually work to create it.

Maybe there should be rules.

I’m just a humble human but I think everybody who willingly worked on or promoted this project should be beaten to death

Enters its new era of rancid dogshit?

This is an article that should have stayed as a draft. Where is Tilly Norwood.... hmmm? Didn't mention that you hack

Is it the era where visionless dipshits shut up about it?

Fuck this noise

“Creativity”

They love AI because they hate art

Spotlight? Sloplight more like.

It is slop and it is theft. You don't need to enquote those words. Tip for your style guide there

i would rather perish than watch ai slop

Stop this AI propaganda!!!

Damn, looks like shit

Don’t show me this shit