Emily Wilson absolutely bodied Nolan because she understood his point entirely, laid it out in a couple paragraphs, and demonstrated why it doesn't work under its own terms. No amount of the "visual language of cinema" can make a narrative fighting itself coherent.
Return of the CmonmacquesShe 100% understands what Nolan is trying to say. She lays it out clearly. And like all of Nolan’s work, when you lay out clearly what he is trying to say, the result is far less impressive than people think. He’s an amazing filmmaker. But he has no idea how to lay out a coherent narrative.