Подтвердите e-mail

Для публикаций, комментариев, реакций и сообщений подтвердите адрес.

Публикация

I've had the chance to ask several scientists in relevant fields variants of the "would you have gone to Jurassic Park" question and so far no one has ever said "No"

samuel mehr

the most realistic scene in Jurassic Park is when two scientists make a questionable decision — traveling to an undisclosed location with a strange man — on the promise of three years of modest funding

Обсуждение

40 прямых ответов · 97 сообщений

Fully funded research for three years? Sign me up!!! Most people don't appreciate the overheads of universities. Fully funded is huge.

I mean, we have real life examples of scientists going to an island with a shady billionaire for the promise of funding

You can add me to your tally. Jurassic Park inspired me to get a PhD in genetics! If you asked me right now if I want to go to the park my answer would be:

Pam from The Office says Absolutely, I do.ALT: Pam from The Office says Absolutely, I do.static.klipy.com

“It’s incredibly unethical, but also dinosaurs”

Ответ для ex-Lethality Jane

I think you're overthinking it. The global economy is about to collapse because rich dipshits are pouring money into unprofitable AI tech that everyone hates. The answer to, "why would they keep doing it," is, "investors are actually really stupid."

Ответ для PJ Westin

Investors might be ghouls, but they also want to see a dinosaur

Ответ для PhantasmSam

Do they want to see a Dino or eat one?

Ответ для Watt Whatley

por que no los dos

Ответ для Watt Whatley

First one, then the other.

Ответ для Watt Whatley

investors are trying to crack

Ответ для PJ Westin

I dont think " Dinosaurs cool" is "overthinking it" xD also they did not try to force Dinosaurs on people. The " Dinosaurs fleeing the island and are everybodys problem now " was not part of the Plan so its not a good comparison.

Ответ для BasementSkeleton

We also know why they insist on AI. Because Gen AI needs to make money kne day to exist and they need it to generate a secound reality for conservatives to live in so they feel good voting against their interests.

Ответ для ex-Lethality Jane

One of my biggest problems with Jurassic World is the whole "we need designer dinosaurs because people are bored of them" plot. Bullshit. People are perfectly happy to see the same zebra at the zoo for the thousandth time. It would take several lifetimes before anyone got bored of a goddamn T. rex.

Ответ для Lindsay (Tired Version)

Look, the "people are tired of dinosaurs" opening to the latest movie is the biggest stretch as far as believability is concerned.

Ответ для Andrew Wilson

They didn’t even try to make it believable. “People are so obsessed with dinosaurs we need to tear down old growth forest for new dinosaurs parks” is right there

Ответ для ex-Lethality Jane

Oh yeah. Easiest “yes” of my life.

No one got into science because they just needed a gig. Every scientist that made it past a bachelor’s degree did so because their curiosity outweighed the need for money and personal time. Not sure you’re ever going to find one that would say “No.”

Ответ для Spencer Watson

If you say so. Put a dozen scientists in the raptor cage and yell BUDGET COMITTEE before the fun starts and I'll give you even odds all 6 walk out wearing new handbags

"What's that?," is still the world's greatest unsung villain.

Aside from the obvious sociological reasons, there's also the fact that....real animals don't behave like they do in the movies. They aren't as persistent or as eager to hunt low-reward targets like humans, especially if they're way bigger than us. They'd still be dangerous, but not like JP dinos.

Ответ для Danni Jo 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈

Like don't get close to them (including the herbivores) and don't make yourself an easy target, but also real predators are going to only hunt when they need food and are going to go after easier / safer meals before they go after animals with technology they don't understand and scarce meat.

Ответ для Danni Jo 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈

But like a t-rex is not going to get a particularly useful number of calories by eating humans. They might snap one up if it's right in front of them or infringing on their territory, but they're not going to put serious effort into chasing us IRL.

Ответ для Danni Jo 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈

The raptors might still be a problem, but even they probably wouldn't be any more dangerous than a pack of wolves. And probably just as likely to avoid humans if possible.

Ответ для Danni Jo 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈

(And would quickly retreat if some of them got injured, as we would have proven ourselves to be more trouble than we're worth--predators want prey they can take down fairly safely using their standard tactics, not dangerous new prey that they can't eat without too much risk or innovation)

Ответ для Danni Jo 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈

Admittedly the book does at least paper over it a bit saying that because Hammond is a dickhead the original dozen raptors were raised wrong, undersocialized as highly social animals, and became unreasonably aggressive as well as maneaters, and that this is extremely not normal animal behaviour.

Ответ для Danni Jo 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈

I think you're underfactoring the fact that the low-reward targets were annoying

Ответ для Tiny Brontosaurus

Well yes, "don't annoy the wildlife" should probably be rule 1 in any survival situation.

If Jurassic Park was real and there was a 50/50 chance of the dinosaurs escaping and eating me, I'd probably still go.

Of course I'd go to Jurassic Park. What kind of a question is that? If I'm going to be eradicated by the monsters unleashed by egomaniac grifters with more money than sense anyway, I'd much rather they be dinosaurs than unregulated gambling and global famine.

Having *watched* the movie, I would still probably say yes.

I don't think this is scientist-exclusive. If you painted 'STABLE INCOME IN YOUR FIELD OF CHOICE' on the side of a windowless van I'd probably get in.

Ask the question here and frame it in terms of what Colossal is doing. You. Will. Get. An. Earful.

Now here's the question, Would you Go?

I would totally have gone even if they'd told me beforehand there had been some accidental deaths because are you fucking kidding me dinosaurs!

Ответ для James "transcendental medication" Dominguez

like disney has zero dinosaurs but more than zero accidental deaths so

Ответ для Tiny Brontosaurus

I was told, by an academic no less, that when the pirates of the Carribbean breaks down the pirates don't start eating the guests.

Ответ для Huw Swanborough
Ответ для James "transcendental medication" Dominguez

Yeah, I've heard this about Florida.

You couldn't stop me from getting into that fucking helicopter

Ответ для Reverend Jesus "H" Christ

I would have to be violently restrained

Ответ для Reverend Jesus "H" Christ

let_me_in.gif

Ответ для Reverend Jesus "H" Christ

Meeting my ancestors with song and story about getting eaten by dinosaurs. Doesn't get much better than that

🙋‍♀️ Do those scientists know what happened the last time other scientists went to Jurassic Park or is this a greenfield question for them?

I watched Jurassic Park in full for the first time last night. My take was I’d have let the dinosaurs have those kids. They were too dumb and annoying to live.

They're lying to themselves, if you wouldn't go there's something wrong with your brain. They're fucking dinosaurs.

It wouldn't be the worst island that prominent scientists have been going to

Ответ для Ang

There's literally an island that's nothing but a pile of bat droppings that has been the subject of study bc those droppings are fertilizer

Ответ для Rachael the Spicy Hobbit

Edit* they're seabird droppings

I think even if you gave the caveat that they would be eaten by a dinosaur the answer would be the same.

Ответ для WalkingTaako🏴‍☠️🏳️🪣💩

We all have to depart this earth sometime. Why not by dinosaur?

Ответ для Hammerhead Snark

This is how I feel about Mount Rainier erupting as well.

Geologists: Mount Rainier Will Not Erupt During Your Lifetime, with Possible Exception of Very EndWashington state geologists confirmed today that, according to their most recent research study, Mount Rainier definitely won’t erupt at any point during your lifetime, with the possible exception …theneedling.com
Ответ для WalkingTaako🏴‍☠️🏳️🪣💩

You’d be the first human to be eaten by a dinosaur. I’d love to be the first human to die on the moon.

How deep into tenure were they? I know some grad students that would bury a Bowie knife in a stranger's chest TO THE HILT.

Who would turn down a weekend vacation to a tropical island for three years of funding? Even without the dinosaurs that sounds like an amazing opportunity. With the dinosaurs it's fantastic*. *contingent on survival

safe to visit if you’re not greedy imo

Ответ для dustwords

Well let's be honest here, the systems were incredibly unsafe with no redundancy, working on a single mainframe at the mercy of a single employee. The protections from gigantic carnivores was lax at best, and a man died before the park even opened! I'm not sure about the safe to visit part :P

Ответ для ThyGoddess

Spared oh so much expense

Ответ для Wanderer

it was very Elon of him

Ответ для ThyGoddess

They SPARED NO EXPENSE, ok??

Ответ для ThyGoddess

/as their escaping the park "Mr. Hammond, after careful consideration, I think if you beef up your software and security, pay your IT staff more, and maybe, just maybe, stop breeding the fast/intelligent dinosaurs capable of opening doors, I'd consider endorsing your park!" -Dr. Grant

Ответ для ThyGoddess

This is the real reason that Jurassic World is not true to the franchise- the dinosaurs became a lot more indiscriminate in who they ate.

Ответ для ThyGoddess

The three leads also almost all simultaneously show their deep concern and apprehension as soon as the childlike wonder passes and they start asking even the most basic questions regarding operation

Ответ для ThyGoddess

But Hammond spared no expense!

Ответ для ThyGoddess

So, in other words, the movie was incredibly realistic.

Hell, my background's astro, you'll find me at the recruiting office for the Lewis and Clark in the AM

If Jurassic Park invited me to invent the field of Velociraptor Cognition I'd do that job for free lol

I’ve known lots of American archaeologists and field biologists and they would go anywhere to do anything for anyone at any time Their foreign counterparts however are properly funded by their respective governments so would never end up being chased by dinosaurs

Ответ для Diedrich Bader

Speaking as an archaeologist, you're things of paleontologists. BUT You're not fucking wrong either/

Ответ для DigsUpDeadFolksStuff

so many typos...

Ответ для DigsUpDeadFolksStuff

Noted But i got the gist

Ответ для Diedrich Bader

Classicist...can confirm I would sure as hell consider the funding if I were working in my field.

Ответ для DigsUpDeadFolksStuff

Yeah, but I’ve only known one paleontologist so that’s not enough to make a graph

Ответ для DigsUpDeadFolksStuff

dinosaur archaeology is a stunted field because you people keep expatriating all our regalia to put in your museums

Ответ для Diedrich Bader

Ugh. Now I want Jurassic Park with fancy accents.

Ответ для Diedrich Bader

And Richard Hammond knew this, which is why he got Grant and Satler and Malcolm. All Americans, desperate for funding and a weekend at a tropical paradise.

That place is like scientist Valhalla

Curiosity is a cautionary tale

Ответ для Wanderfound

Scientist Gamer 🤝 How FAR can i pull the lever?

Well, yes. You dont just turn down Grant money.

To be fair, I have known guys who would do far more in search of sex or drugs

Ответ для Dangerouslytalented

And it’s essentially the reason Epstein island existed

“Little St. James? They told me this was Isla Nublar!”

My mom took me to see Jurassic Park so I took her to see Jurassic World and she asked me after if I would still go, instantly, I said "yes, 100%, I would live there" You couldn't stop me from trying to pet every dinosaur there.

Ответ для Dave Starfighter

If not friend, why friend-shaped?

Even knowing the ending Id still sign up. My toxic trait is believing that my childhood love for dinosaurs would somehow shield me from their ripping talons

If anyone would say no to the chance to see live non avian dinosaurs they are either lying or not good people.

Ответ для Monty Blazar

They're the people the dinosaurs would eat

Ответ для Valraven, Trans Gengar

People so truly altruistic they will feed the dinosaurs with their own flesh.

Ответ для Valraven, Trans Gengar

everyone's always talking about eating when stomping is also a perfectly valid dinosaur folkway

A sum of money to continue my research? How deep of a hole did you say?

I can speak for the paleontology community and say most of us would go knowing we had a 50% chance of being eaten.