DOOM
Профиль
Alan Zilberman
Film critic at Washington City Paper
4,3 тыс. подписчиков521 подписок6 тыс. постов
Публикации
Between this and the Noah Kahan concert last month, we are one instance away from "concert fan shits themselves" becoming a trend. Where will it happen next? I'm looking at you, Lollapalooza (cc @imleor.bsky.social).
Follow more cultural critics! We're still around yakking about our areas of expertise, just with not so many followers, and it beats litigating Stancil or whatever for the umpteenth time.
Alex Brown 🇵🇸 (they/them)*whispers* you know we can do this cultural debate about art thing all the time, right? Websites and news organizations used to have culture critics on staff whose entire job was writing about books, movies, and TV. People read them and then discussed them. We have the technology to do this again.
In the age of rage bait, the true metric of greatness is the degree to which folks online are deliberately obtuse so they can interpret art in the least flattering light.
Josh SpiegelChristopher Nolan truly is one of the great filmmakers like Scorsese, Spielberg, and Hitchcock, since every one of his films is met with a wave of criticism from people actively determined to Not Get It.
Now that David Jonsson has been announced as the new Black Panther, I highly recommend you watch Wasteman, a prison thriller starring Jonsson that's newly available to stream on MUBI. Tough, provocative, oddly moving. Here's what I wrote about it for @spectrumculture.bsky.social a few months ago.
⟳ Репост от Alan Zilberman
Adaptations, as Wilson writes, “needn’t and shouldn’t follow the original with anything like the exactitude of a translation.” But in her takedown of The Odyssey she is more interested in critiquing a film that she wants, not what Nolan made. That might make for conversation, but it’s bad criticism.
www.lrb.co.ukOdyssey translator Emily Wilson thinks the Nolan film "never shows the POV of [Odysseus'] victims," which is wrong. Just because someone is a brilliant translator/academic does not necessarily mean they're also a sharp arts critic. And as others pointed out, the Circe scene also centers victims.
Alan ZilbermanI think Wilson is factually incorrect. Not only does the film portray Sinon as one of Odysseus' victims, the scene where you get his POV is the moral lynchpin of the movie, and you can make the case Zendaya's character is a manifestation of his all his Trojan victims.