Подтвердите e-mail

Для публикаций, комментариев, реакций и сообщений подтвердите адрес.

←

Публикация

Обсуждение

3 прямых ответов · 12 сообщений

Mac

I’m here on the front line fighting alongside you, soldier

Ответ для Mac
Mac

Moffat setting up a big epic finale, then foregoing it in favor of an intimate character study deconstructing Clara and The Doctor’s relationship? We used to be so well fed.

Your good friend, Chris Normal

Clara's funny to me because she can be both the best and second worst companion of the Moffat era depending on context

Ответ для Your good friend, Chris Normal
James Wood

I’ll shoot you?

Ответ для James Wood
Your good friend, Chris Normal

I'll have to go into more detail later, but I'll say this much: Capaldi companion good, Smith companion bad. Plus episodes vs arcs is another factor

Ответ для Your good friend, Chris Normal
Your good friend, Chris Normal

Anyway the long version is she suffers from Moffats belief that a woman can only be interesting if she's a mystery to be solved and the combination of the chemistry with Capaldi and actually being allowed to have a personality that she manages to break out into being a worthwhile character.

Ответ для Your good friend, Chris Normal
James Wood

You’re not wrong! Though I personally think the Impossible Girl shit is both sporadically charming due to her chemistry with Smith and also kind of a necessary thematic/meta text precursor to where they eventually take her.

Ответ для James Wood
Your good friend, Chris Normal

The Danny Pink stuff also sucks but that's due to him sucking, not her. And hell, the fact that she's able to be discussed like this makes her far more of an interesting character than all the Fam of 13

Ответ для Your good friend, Chris Normal
James Wood

Danny is a nothing presence but it does enable Clara’s full tilt into “fuck it” so I can never be too mad about him. And yes, I had until this exact moment, forgotten there was an era between Moffat’s end and RTD’s return.

Ответ для James Wood
Your good friend, Chris Normal

He does enable it but it's hard not to be think the whole time "Him?"

Ответ для Your good friend, Chris Normal
Your good friend, Chris Normal

Which come to think of it, is the Doctors whole reaction too

Rose Skye

The correct opinion 🫡