⟳ Репост от Prof Rachel Oliver
Shadow use of genAI as a reviewer is shitty because you're putting someone else's work into the machine w/o consent, and as an author I'd rather hear Reviewer 2's bad attitudes than LLM platitudes. But if you sanction reviewers you'll just have no reviewers. It's a lose-lose situation.
Margot Finn'IOP Publishing...does not allow the use of AI in its peer review policy, but it believes that generative AI use has skyrocketed nonetheless. As a result, the publisher is trying out a new system that sees reviewers receive a warning where AI use is suspected.' 1/3