Подтвердите e-mail

Для публикаций, комментариев, реакций и сообщений подтвердите адрес.

Публикация

"ok emily wilson's film criticism isn't wrong but she's being pedantic and annoying" damn okay i already supported her perspective but now i'm supporting her character even more

Обсуждение

Ответы

"pedantic and annoying" SHE'S AN EXPERT? My god, the misogyny.

I agree with almost everything she says. Saw Odyssey the first day. Nolan can't write dialogue is exactly what I said when leaving the theater. The acting was subpar IMHO. I often thought while watching, Where is the director?

Ответ для araritsu yuri zone (yumemita spoilers)

what do you mean criticism is critical? what the fuck??

Ответ для araritsu yuri zone (yumemita spoilers)

Girl who just heard about disagreeing with reviews

as a classicist she is so right

"She's not being properly deferential to the capitalist forces that gave her book sales." OK, damn, you got her over, you don't have to keep selling me, I'm on board!

Real

there's a sort of intellectual brainrot in 'fandom' where you are not permitted to criticize anything or else the swarms of fans will get angry. to be honest, i can hardly think of a piece of media I've watched/played/read that i haven't had at least one critique of

Very much enjoyed her criticism, but not quite as much as I enjoyed the film. Now waiting for the Tarantino version.

the amount of stock people put into these nolan movies resembles some kind of patriotism. its baffling seeing real people act like it's treasonous to point out how they're pretty boring

Ответ для immortal woman

Emily Wilson is one of few people willing to point out how minorities are reserved to subordinate roles; the backlash to her take launders segregationalist sentiment along with the more obvious misogyny

i have blocked two men already this morning thank you for creating this post

that's just how you're supposed to talk about art?

Some of the things she says IS wrong though. Not academically, but like what the movie actually says and does.

Ответ для Ivan Nemet

She's also VERY correct in saying that filming in the occupied territory of West Sahara is vile and hurts the Sahrawi people. That is actually a horrible decision and is frankly what should be focused on the most imo.

So is it illegal to have any sort of distaste for the tone of any criticism

It’s still so wild to me that this is what has people irate

“She’s a snob!!!!” Good!

Good to know obvious racism like this is ok with you!

bsky.app/profile/kali... what's extra wild is how this is literally just the kind of review people celebrated Roger Ebert for back in the day

kalina2hu

Emily Wilson exactly accurately describes the aim and quality of every Christopher Nolan movie ever I don't get why hoes are mad

I’m sure this petulant attitude is definitely going to help you in life.