TBH the whole "gun and ball gamer" thing has spiraled out of control from its original context lol. But if we take these two terms superficially... The typical gun and ball gamer probably has better taste in games than the potion and sword gamer.
JasonI learned recently that people mad at the label "gun and ball gamer" have taken up trying to make "potion and sword gamer" a thing and I'm sorry but that's awesome my potions and my swords