Подтвердите e-mail

Для публикаций, комментариев, реакций и сообщений подтвердите адрес.

←

Публикация

Предыдущая публикация
gavinner

Not really, film and written epics are quite different media. What is her expertise on film criticism and film production? And if you could keep the personal remarks to a minimum please - no need to get emotional.

200
Jack Scrambo

Please point me to all the times you’ve levied this charge at film critics who bear no expertise whatsoever in any aspect of filmmaking. Hint: it’s almost all of them. You’re a silly person

Обсуждение

1 прямых ответов · 5 сообщений

gavinner

What, that people have gotten overdramatic about a film based on personal dislike rather than being qualified, or missing out basic aspects of the movie? Did you miss half the right wing chuds slating this movie before it was even out? Yeah, there's been a lot of it about.

Ответ для gavinner
Jack Scrambo

You’ve gotten pretty overdramatic about Emily Wilson’s review in a manner that is at least chud adjacent

Ответ для Jack Scrambo
gavinner

Not really. She's well capable of criticising the adaptation, but the criticism of the film as a film is out of her lane more. She's also not helping though by her weird racial hot takes and dismissiveness towards trauma of war. Not surprising the chuds love her review now.

Ответ для gavinner
Jack Scrambo

Chuds hate her. You’re twisting yourself into knots to disqualify a qualified person’s film review. You reek of double standards. Very chudlike

Ответ для Jack Scrambo
gavinner

Chuds are glad to see her review. I know I haven't just broadbrushed an Indian actor as black or underplayed various performances of nonwhite actors as just black friend tropes. And I'm sure there's nothing at all to the fact that half the time Troy is mentioned in the poem Odysseus cries