Art critique is itself an art form, and like all art it is subjective, requires practice, and is as much about the critic themself as it is about the subject it critiques.
Aaron BadyA lot of backlash to Wilson's take on Nolan's film personalized the issue, often in response to how her review was (rightly or wrongly) viewed to have been "personal." A lot of the defenses of her review (the backlash to that backlash) were also very personal, but inverted, praising her.