I actually think this would be amazing, if the second Sinner redeemed isn't any of the main cast, but is like Rooster, Ant Dude, or Fruit Tree Lady. Pentious is all ready to be reunited with his friends, but up pops someone he never met. And they're like, "WELL I'VE HEARD ALL ABOUT YOU, BUDDY."
Scalawag JackYes, Justice for Rooster! Though NGL it'd actually be kind of funny if he gets quietly redeemed in the background of S3 and just shows up in heaven. "Oh, hey, Rooster," S3 Emily.