It was all supposed to be a collective celebration of Nolan's success, a solid thumping of Musk and the like, and she had the nerve to offer informed critique, a thing social media's lack of nuance rarely allows, ergo the reaction...
For the record, this Emily Wilson Odyssey review furor is ridiculous, and largely fueled by algorithms designed to work us up over practically nothing. She wrote a very interesting review from her perspective and I personally enjoyed it. Now, it feels like people want her arrested for a crime.